Warming

Marisha Plotnik

From In Context #56 (Spring 2026) | View Article as PDF

In December of 2025, The Nature Institute hosted a visit from Matthias Rang, a physicist and co-chair of the Natural Science Section at the Goetheanum, and Meinhard Simon, a biologist long associated with the work of the science section. During their visit, they offered the evening presentation, "The Warmth Mantle of the Earth: Two Perspectives." Meinhard took us on a journey through time, describing how the earth has been differently warm during the stages of its evolution. Matthias took us on a journey through the layers of the atmosphere, describing what he discovered using a weather ballon with sensors able to detect radiative warmth: warmth streaming up from the surface of the earth, and warmth streaming down from the atmosphere. 

Here at The Nature Institute, we took up these questions of the warmth of the earth in our Climate Colloquia with science teachers over a number of years. It is clear that a simplistic image of a greenhouse — a static, closed, isolated system where humid air is trapped inside and grows increasingly warm on sunny days — is insufficient to describe the complex dynamics of how the earth warms and cools in constant exchange with the cosmos. Indeed, this image does not even describe the dynamics of an actual greenhouse, which is never an isolated system. Consider, for example, how the inside is warmed or cooled by the ground on which it rests. 

A more complete picture of the warmth of the earth must take into consideration the entire earth and cosmos. The solid rocky mantle of the earth (lithosphere), the movements of the water (hydrosphere), the air (atmosphere), and the living beings (biosphere): all contribute and respond in different ways to the processes of warming and cooling. All of these dynamics take place in relationship to the entire starry cosmos — with the particularly important role of the sun — that surrounds our earth. How then can we develop a more accurate and nuanced understanding of warming?

Materials that are in contact warm and cool each other in the manner we name conduction. Picking up a stone from the shaded path on an autumn day I find the stone cools my hand even as my hand warms the stone. Setting the warm stone down, it gently warms the air touching it from above and the earth touching it from below. All these phenomena are instances of conduction. Every substance conducts warmth differently: metals like iron and copper and aluminum are wonderfully effective conductors. When I place my cast-iron frying pan on the flame of my stove top, the entire pan, including the handle, soon grows hot. Woe is me if I forget to use a pot-holder! Air and water, however, are very poor conductors. Indeed, the thermos I use to keep my soup hot has a layer of air insulating the contents so that the warmth of the soup is contained and does not spread to the outside of the thermos. Notably, in conduction the conductive medium (e.g. the frying pan) stays still, and it is the warmth that moves through the conductor.

The phenomenon of conduction is intensely local, arising only in situations of bodily contact. When there is no active source of heat, this bodily continuity always means that the cooler parts grow warmer while the warmer parts grow cooler. This reciprocal exchange of warming and cooling demonstrates how warmth is always a dynamic relationship and never a quality that can be fixed or stored.

While conduction phenomena are most prevalent in and around the largely still, solid bodies of the earth, air and water move with the dynamics of convection. Warm fluids — gases and liquids both — typically rise, creating convection currents that circulate, spreading warmth far and wide. The hawk circling on a thermal rising from the valley below me makes visible how the air, warmed by the land, is now rising upward. The immensely varied surface of our earth warms differently — rocky desert more than forest or grassland more than ocean. The bodies warm the air from below and this creates differentiated air currents both large and small. 

More mysterious than either conduction or convection is the phenomenon of radiation. Radiative warming requires no medium at all: neither the still metals that conduct so effectively nor the dynamic fluids that carry warmth by convection. Radiative warming is happening when, for instance, the sun warms my face on a winter's day despite the cold air all around. Even if we think of the sun as a celestial object separated from earth by vast distances of empty space, we still find the sun's warming activity right here in our earthly home. This is a radiation phenomenon.

The polar opposites of conductive warming, which reaches its pinnacle with dense metals, and radiative warming, which needs no intervening substance at all, share strong resemblances to sound and light respectively. Sound waves travel effectively through dense materials: think of putting an ear to the railway track to hear the approaching train still many miles away. (Readers accustomed to associating sound with sinusoidal vibrations may be interested to learn that the 19th century mathematical physicist Joseph Fourier intensively studied the phenomenon of thermal conduction in metals and found that they also have a sinusoidal nature. Indeed, the tremendously powerful technique of the Fourier Transformation, which enables any curve to be described as a superposition of individual sine curves, was created by Fourier out of his studies of thermal conduction in metals.)

Radiative warming, on the other hand, is strongly connected to light and color. When the clouds part on an early spring day, the visible world grows bright at the same time as my cool hands are warmed by the sun. Just as the objects about me reveal themselves in different colors, they also grow differently warm. A black asphalt road warms up considerably, while a white-painted roof warms much less. Materials that are highly responsive to radiative warming themselves become sources of radiation. That hot asphalt road now radiates its warmth out to its surroundings, something we notice particularly in the night after a hot day.

Other materials are largely unaffected. One can say that they are transparent to radiative warming. On a cold, bright winter's day, I am drawn towards the sunny window and can feel the sun's warmth when I sit where the floor is brightly illuminated. Any cat will do the same, basking in the sunny patch near the window. But placing my hand against the window pane, I find it icy cold to the touch. The glass of the window is largely transparent to both the light and also the warmth of the sun. It allows the sun to enter the room to warm and illuminate the objects inside, while the glass itself neither brightens nor warms. Stepping outside, I find that the dry winter air is also largely transparent to the light and warmth. The February wind blowing across my face is cold, but the sun on my face is warm. This dry air warms almost not at all, but it allows the warmth of the sun to pass through it to warm the objects in its path.

Surprisingly, it is not only glass and dry air that are largely transparent to radiative warming, but ice and, to a lesser extent, snow are as well. Try freezing some water on a dark-colored plate and then, on a very cold day, place that plate outside in the sun. The ice will melt, even when the air temperature is well below freezing. But it will not melt from the top, instead the ice will melt from below. The ice itself is transparent to the radiative warmth of the sun, but the plate is not. The plate warms and the warm plate melts the ice sitting on it. A thin layer of snow will similarly be largely transparent to radiative warming, but the stone walkway or the wood of the deck below will be warmed and will melt the snow from below.  

In the small examples above, we can think through the delicate interweaving of the three kinds of warming: radiative, conductive, and convective. In each case, the underlying material (plate, deck) is radiatively warmed by the sun. That material then conductively warms the ice or snow in contact with it. On the plate, the melted ice, now liquid water, begins to circulate, carrying the warmth of the plate up to the ice on top, melting increasingly more ice during the sun-warm day.

On a much larger scale, we can picture the sun radiatively warming the earth through the transparent air during the bright day and, during the dark night, the earth radiating its warmth back into the cosmos. A kind of rhythmic breathing of warmth takes place with the earth inhaling warmth in the day and exhaling it again at night. I recall once in a dry Texas spring sitting on a giant rock ledge at sunset. As the sun took its light and warmth below my horizon, I grew increasingly aware of the giant rock mantle warming me from below. By morning, both the rock and I would have grown cold, only to be warmed again by the sun rising above the opposite horizon.

Moist air creates a different situation entirely. Not only in the tropics, but here in the northeastern United States in the summer months, we can experience how the thick, humid air, warmed by the sun during the day, remains warm long after the sun has set. The warm night breezes of July are entirely different than the cold dry winds of February even on bright sunny days when the sun is warming my face. While the dry February air remains transparent to the streaming winter sun, allowing the sun to warm my face while the air itself remains cold, the moist July air is itself warmed by the sun. The summer wind carries warmth and continues to warm its surroundings — by convection and radiation both — even after the sun has set.

So we can imagine how the earth creates its own mantle of warmth, releasing water from its solid and liquid states to become part of the air itself. Mist rising off a pond; fog rolling in from the sea; dew vanishing in the early morning: all this liquid water is on its way to uniting with the air around us. The steam billowing out of my teakettle in the morning is still tiny droplets of liquid water, but when the steam is no longer visible then the water has entered its gaseous state and has become true water vapor. Water vapor is ever-present in the air around us: dry air has a much lower concentration of water vapor and humid air a higher concentration. All around us, especially in warmer weather, water is transitioning from its liquid to its vapor form; sometimes passing through visible stages like fog and mist and steam, and sometimes making the transition invisibly. When the leaves of the maple tree outside my window are grown large and green, the tree transpires hundreds of gallons of water vapor on each day of its leafy season. We can picture now the earth's water in its temperate zones leaving the air during the winter months to settle into ponds and streams, snow and ice, and then rising again to join the air as the days grow longer and the sun rises higher in our sky.  

This ever-moving, circulating, hydrosphere of the earth is the most important system keeping our temperatures within a range that supports all the living organisms now on earth — including human beings. But water vapor is not the only gas that enables air to lose its transparency and instead grow warm. Carbon dioxide is also one of the "greenhouse gases," and through its presence air is able to become warm through radiative warming. Carbon, like water, is in its own constant cycling between solid and gaseous forms, but here the cycling relies not just on physical changes of state but on complex organic and inorganic chemical processes. One of these cycles is that of photosynthesis and respiration. In these life processes, green leaves create sugars from water and carbon dioxide, and respiring beings eat these leaves for nourishment and exhale carbon dioxide gas back into the air. A much longer, slower, carbon cycle takes place among rainwater, rocks such as limestone, marble, or chalk, and the organisms who make shells in the ocean water. 

Carbon dioxide is present in our air in only very small concentrations (currently roughly 0.043% or 430 parts per million) but, unlike water vapor, it is able to rise high into the upper layers of the atmosphere. Water vapor primarily stays close to the earth, in the lower layers of the atmosphere, where we can observe it passing through different changes of phase in the formation and dissipation of clouds. But carbon dioxide can rise higher than the highest clouds, into the stratosphere. At these enormous altitudes, this carbon dioxide has been isolated off from the carbon cycles of the biosphere and can no longer participate in them. Once it reaches the stratosphere, carbon dioxide has its most significant effect on the warming of the earth. Scientists believe that carbon dioxide is a lasting presence in the stratosphere, changing the balance of warming and cooling between the earth and the cosmos. (1) 

One can say that in our over-consumption of the abundance of ancient life — our excessive burning of fossil fuels — too much carbon has been removed from the activity of life and trapped in gaseous form at the boundary between the earth and the cosmos. Even in minute concentrations, the increased presence of carbon dioxide in the stratosphere is altering the warmth relationship between the earth and the cosmos, with powerful consequences for the climate and weather that all living beings experience.

Warmth is not a "thing," but instead we can observe dynamic processes of warming and cooling in the solid bodies of the earth, in the liquid and gaseous spheres of earth, and in all of the earth's living being. These processes happen in highly differentiated ways with different materials, and by these three very different modes of conduction, convection, and radiation. When we incorrectly make warmth into an object, we imagine that we can trap it, isolate it, and manage it. However, when we can instead think the processes of warming as relationships among the substances and beings of the earth and of the cosmos, we may be better prepared to foster those relationships in healthier, more sustainable ways.

(1) See, for example, Cohen, S. et al. (2026). "Stratospheric cooling and amplification of radiative forcing with rising carbon dioxide," Nature Geoscience vol. 19, pp. 507-512.

 
Ryan Shea